News

How to Compete With an Internal Job Candidate

Phantom jobs. They look like real job postings, but these positions are secretly pre-promised to internal candidates. For everyone else, these jobs are a waste of good PTO and dry-cleaning costs. And we all hate phantom jobs because we don’t know when we’re applying for them. Nobody likes to be set up to fail. So why the charade? Although this practice isn’t illegal, and federal labor laws don’t require employers to post openings, many HR policies require openings to post as part of a fair hiring process. The good news is, even though internal candidates are your toughest competition, you can stand out against them.

Not all job postings are pre-promised to an internal darling, but you’ll have to make an extra-fabulous showing to compete with someone the company already knows. While internal candidates already know the company’s ins and outs and have built relationships, their history can actually work against them if the interviewers don’t see them as fit for the new role. You, as an external candidate with a solid work history and references, can represent an attractive unknown—the fresh perspective and infusion of talent the company might want.

  • Go in with a plan. How are you going to quickly get up to speed on the company? What do you plan to do with your first 90 days on the job? How can you familiarize yourself with the company’s and department’s policies and procedures? How can you interface with the company’s key teams and players? Let the company know you’ve thought about ways to make your transition quick and successful.
  • Showcase your team-building skills. Should you be chosen for the position, you may have to work alongside your internal competition (who, after being passed over for an outsider, may not be in the most cooperative mood). You might even be asked how you would manage the losing candidate if you were hired. During your interview, be sure to highlight your ability to build and maintain relationships, especially if you’re pursuing a leadership role.
  • Focus on the job, not the competition. Say you’re also an internal candidate, and you’re competing against a coworker. Around the office and before the interview, remember that this process is about choosing the most skilled person for the job, not about cutting down the competition. So keep things on the up and up. Talk about the projects you’ve completed, the education you’ve pursued, and why you’re the best fit for the job, not why the other person isn’t as great a fit. And if the other candidate decides to play dirty, remember that their attitude won’t go unnoticed, and that you don’t have to play that game.
  • If you don’t succeed… and you’re an in-house candidate competing against a coworker, be gracious. Even though you may not understand why you weren’t selected, trust the process and congratulate the other person. After all, you’ll probably be working together. You can also use this opportunity to solicit feedback for improvement from your boss or others on the interview panel. And if you’re an external candidate who lost to an insider, don’t be discouraged. Sometimes companies like to go with what they know, or you may have stumbled into one of those pesky phantom jobs. It doesn’t mean your skills aren’t amazing, so try, try again!

YES! News

The “better” way to conduct layoffs

Layoffs are hard on everyone. Even as business leaders and HR professionals, layoffs are one of the hardest things we have to do. Regrettably, many of us remember this from the all-too-recent pandemic layoffs. Layoffs are a reality we may soon face again as the threat of recession looms. And while we may not have […]

Resolve conflict like a champ

We’re hard-pressed to say conflict resolution is a fun or glamorous part of a Human Resources or leadership role, but it’s one of the most critical parts. How you mediate conflict impacts employee morale and retention, and also shows your leadership abilities and your willingness to tackle the tough stuff. Your conflict resolution skills can […]

Stop! and hire this candidate

It’s easy to criticize potential hires and spot reasons why we shouldn’t hire them. That one is too arrogant, that one lacks technical skills, and that one knows nothing about the company. Process of elimination, right? But too often we fail to recognize the positive reasons why we should hire someone. Positive flags can be […]

Client Testimonials

"Kathi has been an extremely reliable, knowledgeable and indispensable resource for our growing business. Anytime we had a difficult issue or needed to refine, replace or upgrade our HR communication, Kathi provided outstanding support and feedback. She is a wonderful person and an outstanding, solution oriented communicator. I can't recommend her enough to businesses who need assistance with HR strategy and support."

"Kathi is reliable, knowledgeable, and an excellent communicator. She has always been readily available to help us with all of our immediate needs, from handbooks to policies, and notices. We highly recommend her. A great team player."

"SPMD has been partnering with Kathi for almost 4 years. She is a fantastic partner to our design firm. Her experience, knowledge, professionalism and ability to problem solve is the perfect package to fit our business. Over the years she has helped us navigate many employee situations quickly and re-wrote our Employee Handbook. Kathi is always there in a heartbeat when a situation arises and has the answers and advice we need. We highly recommend Kathi!"

“Kathi provided Senior Human Resources leadership to Orqis Medical for over six years. Her effectiveness is immediate, her contributions substantial, and her ability to integrate into the employee base as a consultant outstanding. I highly recommend Kathi to any company looking for senior management help in the HR arena, without the ability to hire a full-time manager. This is a go-to person for any small, medium, or start-up company.”

    Shine Video Star Job Interview

    Free Consultation

    Contact Us

    • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.